1. Introduction: The Legal Architecture and Grace Periods Hidden Behind the "2035 Total ICE Phase-Out" Slogan

For several years, headlines about the global car industry and energy markets have been full of sweeping claims. A typical one reads: "by 2035, gasoline and diesel cars will disappear entirely." Some praise this as a historic step toward tackling the climate crisis and reaching carbon neutrality. Many drivers, though, feel anxious. They wonder whether they will be unable to drive their current cars just ten years from now. Others are skeptical because of electric-vehicle fires and the inconvenience of charging.

Yet the actual texts of laws passed by legislatures and of government administrative orders tell a different story. The real system does not work as a single, across-the-board 'sales ban.'

In legal terms, the goal is not to criminalize or confiscate the internal combustion engine as a machine. Instead, the rules measure the average tailpipe greenhouse gas emissions of the 'new vehicles (new registrations)' that manufacturers bring to market. They then force those emissions down to zero, in stages, by a set year. In other words, internal combustion cars already purchased may still be driven legally even after 2035. Used-car trading is also permitted.

Countries have also built in sophisticated legal buffers. These include e-fuel (synthetic fuel) exceptions, recognized shares for plug-in hybrids (PHEVs), and manufacturer sales quotas for interim years. Each country shaped these buffers to fit its own industrial base, power-grid conditions, and political compromises.

This article draws on the statutes and official government statistics of the European Union, Germany, the United Kingdom, Norway, and the United States. Using them, it lays out the real timetable for moving away from internal combustion cars, and the practical limits on that shift.

2. Regulation (EU) 2023/851: Binding 100% Cuts by 2035 and 2030 Interim Targets

The top-level legal basis for the EU's timetable is 'Regulation (EU) 2023/851 of the European Parliament and of the Council,' adopted in April 2023. The European Parliament's official legislative explanation gives the reasoning. Road transport produces about one-fifth (20%) of the EU's total carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. More than 70% of that comes from passenger cars and light commercial vehicles (vans). So the EU thoroughly revised its emissions standards for new vehicles. It did this as part of 'Fit for 55,' the legal package for reaching climate neutrality by 2050.

Under this regulation, from January 1, 2035, all new passenger cars and vans sold and registered within the EU must cut their tailpipe emissions by 100% against the 2021 baseline. Because this means tailpipe emissions must be 0g CO2/km, in practice only pure battery electric vehicles (BEVs) and hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) will be able to meet the standard. To prevent an abrupt shock to the market, however, legislators set an interim 2030 target: by 2030 passenger cars must achieve a 55% CO2 reduction and light commercial vehicles a 50% reduction. The regulation further specifies that a manufacturer failing to meet its emissions target must pay an enormous excess emissions premium (penalty) of €95 for each gram per kilometer of excess, multiplied by each registered vehicle.

Electric vehicles plugged into high-power fast chargers at a public charging station
High-power EV fast-charging stations expanding alongside national phase-out targets for new internal combustion vehicles · Oregon Department of Transportation · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

This shows that the regulation targets the emissions of new cars, not the engine as such. Given the 2030 interim targets and the penalties, the pressure on manufacturers can be read as starting well before 2035.

3. Germany's Negotiation of the E-Fuel (Synthetic Fuel) Exception: The Technical Survival Line of the Internal Combustion Engine and Its Practical Limits

The fiercest diplomatic clash during the final passage of Regulation (EU) 2023/851 was over exactly this point: 'Germany's objection and the e-fuels exception.'

Before the final vote in March 2023, Germany's Federal Ministry for Digital and Transport (BMDV) temporarily blocked adoption of the law. It was responding to demands from high-performance sports car makers such as Porsche and from the precision machinery components industry. The ministry wanted a guarantee for internal combustion cars running solely on 'carbon-neutral fuel (e-fuel).' This fuel is synthesized using carbon capture technology and renewable electricity. Germany wanted such cars to remain eligible for registration after 2035.

The European Commission eventually proposed a compromise. It added a provision to the regulation's preamble (Recital 11). This provision pledged to prepare the technical legislation (a delegated act) needed to register vehicles that run exclusively on e-fuels. As a result, the internal combustion engine itself escaped permanent legal eradication.

Bodies such as the International Energy Agency (IEA) and the European Environment Agency (EEA) have analyzed e-fuels, however. They find that e-fuels deliver only one-fourth to one-fifth the well-to-wheel energy efficiency of pure electric vehicles. Electric cars charge electricity directly into a battery to drive a motor. Making e-fuels, by contrast, consumes enormous amounts of green hydrogen and electricity. This makes each unit very expensive to produce.

So experts broadly agree that e-fuels are unlikely to power mass-market vehicles. Instead, they will likely remain a niche technology for expensive sports cars and classic cars. They may also serve special sectors such as aviation and shipping, where electrification is impossible.

This shows that being permitted by law and surviving in the market are separate matters. The e-fuel clause reads less as an exit route for mass-market cars than as a narrow exception.

Wind turbine above a plant with a green tank and industrial buildings on grassland
Haru Oni e-fuel pilot plant near Punta Arenas, Chile, 2026 · Ildottoreverde · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

4. The UK's Zigzag Course and the ZEV Mandate: The 2030 Phase-Out and Manufacturer Quotas (from 22% to 80%)

The UK's nominal target year for phasing out internal combustion engines has been adjusted several times amid political controversy. But the legal mechanism behind it has taken shape as a very powerful quota system.

In November 2020, the British government announced its 'Ten Point Plan for a Green Industrial Revolution.' It declared that sales of new pure petrol and diesel cars would end by 2030. In September 2023, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak postponed the target by five years, to 2035. He cited the need to ease the burden on consumers. The Labour government that took office in July 2024 is taking a phased approach. It restores 2030 as the end date for sales of new pure internal combustion cars, while allowing hybrid models until 2035.

More important than the media's political sparring over timelines, however, is the UK's actual statute. It is 'The Vehicle Emissions Trading Schemes Order 2023 (SI 2023 No. 1355),' which formally came into force on January 1, 2024. This law sets out the so-called 'ZEV Mandate.'

Under it, every carmaker selling vehicles in the UK must raise the share of zero-emission vehicles (ZEVs) in its annual passenger car sales. The share rises from 22% in 2024 to 28% in 2025, 52% in 2028, 80% in 2030, and 100% in 2035. Suppose a manufacturer misses this required share and also fails to buy allowances from other manufacturers. It must then pay a punitive fine of £15,000 (about 26 million won) per shortfall vehicle, as of 2024.

In other words, the law already cuts internal combustion car volumes every year through sales quotas. It does so even before any formal, declared ban.

High-voltage lithium-ion battery pack and electric drivetrain chassis of a battery electric vehicle
A high-voltage automotive battery pack mounted in the vehicle floor, central to zero-emission vehicle mandates · Mic from Reading - Berkshire, United Kingdom · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

This shows that even as announced target years shift, it is the quota legislation that actually constrains what manufacturers ship. It also highlights a difference: the EU requires lower average emissions, while the UK sets a required share of sales.

5. Norway's Miracle and the Reality Behind It: An 80–90% Electric Vehicle Share Achieved Through Tax Policy and Infrastructure, Not a Legal 'Ban'

In the global debate over phasing out internal combustion engines, Norway is unquestionably cited as the most advanced model. The Norwegian parliament set a national target early on: all new car sales would be zero-emission vehicles by 2025. Official vehicle registration statistics from Statistics Norway (Statistisk sentralbyrå, SSB) show how far it has come. Pure electric vehicles already made up more than 80% of newly registered passenger cars in 2023–2024. In certain months, the share exceeded 90%. In effect, Norway reached its target ahead of schedule.

Contrary to what many people assume, however, the Norwegian government has never once 'banned' the sale of internal combustion cars through criminal law or coercive administrative measures. Its success came from a sophisticated design of 'taxation and charging infrastructure,' which acted as the decisive driver. This worked against a background of cheap hydropower-based electricity and high income levels.

Norway has traditionally imposed very high registration and emissions taxes on imported vehicles. These made new internal combustion cars astronomically expensive. On top of that, electric cars were fully exempted from the 25% value-added tax (VAT) and from the registration tax. The law also set that they pay no more than 70% of the public highway tolls and ferry fares paid by conventional cars. The result was a price inversion. Within the same vehicle class, taxes made an internal combustion car far more expensive to buy than an electric one.

The real key to Norway's transition had two parts. It led consumers to choose electric vehicles out of economic good sense rather than coercion. It also proactively built a dense network of public fast-charging corridors across the country.

This shows that a high electric-vehicle share does not necessarily require a ban. It also suggests that Norway's backdrop of cheap hydropower and high incomes has to be taken into account alongside its policies.

6. California's CARB ACC II Rules and the Federal EPA: 100% Zero-Emission Vehicles in 2035 and a 20% Plug-In Hybrid Allowance

California, which has the world's fifth-largest economy, is the driving force of U.S. electrification policy. The California Air Resources Board (CARB) finalized the 'Advanced Clean Cars II (ACC II)' regulations. These set mandatory zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) sales shares, stage by stage, from model year 2026 through model year 2035. Manufacturers must start at 35% in 2026 and reach 68% in 2030. By 2035, 100% of the new passenger cars and light trucks they sell in California must be zero-emission.

Notably, CARB did not insist on pure battery electric vehicles (BEVs) alone. Instead, it wrote highly practical flexibility into law. Under the ACC II rules, manufacturers may cover up to 20% of the 100% requirement in 2035 with 'plug-in hybrids (PHEVs).' To qualify, however, a PHEV must travel at least 50 miles (about 80 km) in pure electric mode. It must also meet strict emissions warranty requirements.

More than ten states with large populations and vehicle fleets have adopted California's rules as they stand. They include New York, Washington, and Massachusetts, known as the Section 177 states. Together, these rules directly affect about 40% of the entire U.S. new car market. They also interact with the greenhouse gas emission standards of the federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to press the transition forward.

Curbside electric vehicle charging posts along a residential city street in Europe
On-street residential EV charging posts integrated into urban power distribution networks in Europe · Norsk Elbilforening · CC BY 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

This shows that '100% zero-emission vehicles' does not mean '100% battery electric vehicles.' The difference becomes clear when set beside the EU standard, under which effectively only BEVs and FCEVs qualify.

7. The Wall of Reality: Regional Polarization of Charging Infrastructure, Grid Load, the Shortage of Affordable Models, and the Chasm

Laws and institutions point to ambitious target years. Yet the real-world global picture clearly shows the so-called electric vehicle 'chasm,' in which the pace of the transition falters. The chasm is a temporary stall in demand before mass adoption. The International Energy Agency's (IEA) report Global EV Outlook 2024 makes this point. The initial buying rush among technology early adopters has passed. Now the barriers facing ordinary mainstream consumers remain high.

The first barrier is the extreme regional polarization of charging infrastructure, along with the problem of housing type. Some people live in detached houses and can slow-charge in their garage on cheap late-night electricity. Many ordinary households cannot. They live in apartments or multi-family housing, or must park on the street. At public fast-charging stations, they face a double burden: long waits and relatively expensive rates.

The second barrier is the physical limit of transmission and distribution capacity. When large charging hubs are concentrated in city centers, peak loads on local substations and distribution systems surge. Reinforcing the grid requires permitting periods of several years or more, plus enormous capital investment.

The third barrier is the shortage of affordable models. Some countries, such as Germany and France, are reducing or abolishing government subsidies. There, buyers lack enough economical family-car options in the $20,000–$25,000 range (about 27 million–34 million won). This is turning consumers back toward hybrid (HEV) vehicles. Because of this gap with reality, automakers are making pragmatic adjustments in parallel. They are moderating the pace of their electric vehicle investment and strengthening their hybrid lineups.

This shows that statutory deadlines and the actual pace of adoption can move independently. Compared with Norway, which built its charging corridors early, the deciding factors can be read as charging access and price.

8. What the Eight Threads Together Reveal About the Transition: Not an Across-the-Board Break but an Intricate Realignment of Industry and Regulation

Consider together the statutes and market data reviewed so far from the European Union, Germany, the United Kingdom, Norway, and California. One thing becomes clear. The end of the internal combustion car is not a magical 'break' on some single day. It is a process of multilayered regulatory and market 'realignment.'

First, the law targets makers of new cars, not existing owners. Even after 2030 or 2035, legally registered internal combustion cars can still be driven on the road. Parts supply, the filling-station network, and the used-car market will follow a long soft-landing path. They will shrink gradually over at least 15 to 20 years.

Second, behind the political rhetoric of a 'total ban' lie each country's practical compromises. Examples include the e-fuel provision Germany secured, the 20% high-performance PHEV quota California wrote into law, and the flexibility provisions of the UK's ZEV Mandate. These are institutional safety valves. They acknowledge that electrification infrastructure is incomplete, and they are designed to prevent a collapse of supply chains.

Third, what truly completes the transition is not prohibition laws but the economics of infrastructure. Norway has proved this. Once tax incentives and dense charging corridors are in place, electric cars overwhelm internal combustion cars in running costs and convenience. The market then moves on its own, without legal compulsion. Over the decade or so that remains, global success or failure will not depend on political battles over statutory deadlines. It will depend on how grids are expanded, how low-cost battery innovation is achieved, and how fair access to charging is secured.